I Want to Sue the Police for Arresting Me Again. Do I Have a Right to Sue Them and Go to Trial

Afalse arrest is adetention thatunlawfully restrainsthe victim'sliberty. Bothpolice andprivate citizens tin be held liable for making a false arrest. Constabulary can be sued formonetary damages by the victim in acivil rights lawsuit. When police have illegally arrested someone, the victim can also file a complaint with the police section. If charged with a crime, the victim tin can too enquire a courtroom toexclude whatever evidence was discovered by way of the arrest.

People tin sue for detention that unlawfully restrains their freedom.

one. What is an arrest?

Anarrest requires iii things:

1. an intentional impecuniousness of someone else's liberty of movement,
2. that deprivation compels the victim to get somewhere or to stay somewhere for an appreciable time, and
3. the deprivation was non consensual.^ane

Most of the time, arrests are conducted pastpolice force officers. Notwithstanding, in that location are times when private citizens initiate arrests (citizen'south arrest), such every bit security guards.

Example: A store clerk detains a suspect for shoplifting.

The use of forcefulness is not necessary to initiate an arrest. Arrests tin involve anything that compels the victim'due south movement. This includes:

• force,
• threats,
• duress,
• fraud, or
• deceit.ⁱⁱ

If the arrest involves confinement or physical restraint, it does non accept to be complete restraint. Victims practise non have to be locked in a room with no possibility of escape.³ They do not even need to be aware of their lack of liberty at the fourth dimension of the solitude.⁴

ii. What is a false arrest?

Similar to unlawful detention, falsely absorbing someone is restraining someone without legal justification. Absorbing can be unlawful if the arrestor had no legal authority to do so.

Police enforcement officers exercise not have the legal right to make arrests on a whim. They must have likely cause or awarrant to arrest someone lawfully.

Arresting can exist lawful when information technology begins, but becomes unlawful as it progresses.

Example: A police officer pulls a auto over for a broken taillight. After writing the ticket, the officeholder tells the driver that they are non allowed to leave until a drug-sniffing dog arrives. This is a false arrest case because there is unlawful restraint on the driver'south freedom.

The term false arrest is frequently used interchangeably with false imprisonment. I is just one way of committing the other. Some false arrests occur with constabulary brutality, and some do not.⁵

The deed of police arresting someone can be unlawful even if they take a warrant.

three. Can there be a fake arrest if there is a warrant?

An arrest made past a police officercan be unlawful, fifty-fifty if there was awarrant. Arresting tin can exist unlawful if the warrant was invalid.

An arrest warrant can be invalid if:

• information technology does not proper name or adequately identify the person to be arrested,
• information technology does not specify the crime for which the person is being arrested,
• it does not say what courtroom issued the warrant, or
• police lied to a judge to evidence they had probable crusade for the arrest.

False statements by police have to be integral to the finding of probable cause to invalidate a warrant. If the approximate could have found there was probable cause without the false statements, the warrant is withal valid.^six

Non all invalid warrants atomic number 82 to wrongful arresting, withal. The arresting officer tin defend against a false arrest claim by arguing that he or she was acting in good religion. An officer can evidence a good faith defense by showing that:

• the warrant appeared to be valid,
• the officer believed the warrant was valid, and
• the officeholder had a reasonable belief that the warrant was for the person who was arrested.⁷

iv. What are unlawful and warrantless arrests?

Police are immune to make warrantless arrests. Only these arrests must exist supported byprobable cause. If a police force officer did not accept sufficient probable cause, the arrest wasunlawful. In one case the victim shows that he/she was arrested without a warrant, the officeholder has to prove that in that location was probable crusade.⁸

Police can prove that they had likely cause if:

• the doubtable commits a crime in the officer'south presence, or
• the officer had reasonable cause to believe that the suspect had committed a felony.^nine

The officer's belief is informed past what the officeholder knew, at the fourth dimension of the arrest.^ten

5. What remedies are there for a victim?

Victims of a simulated abort have 4 legal options that they can pursue:

1. acomplaint against the arresting officer with the police department,
2. a motion to suppress any evidence was obtained from the fake arrest,
3. a lawsuit against the officer and department, demanding aninjunction, and
4. a  lawsuit against the officeholder and department, enervatingmonetary amercement.

Past filing acomplaint with the police department, a victim tin demand the officer face repercussions for their false arrest. In the most egregious cases, the officer could get fired. He or she could also be suspended or retrained. In California, an officer could face up criminal charges under Penal Lawmaking 118.1 PC or other statutes.

If the victim was charged with a law-breaking, he or she tin file amove to exclude evidence obtained from the false arrest. This motion is filed with the court in the victim's criminal case. Any criminal show establish considering of the arrest tin can get thrown out.

Victims tin also file a false abort lawsuit against the officer and the police department for civil rights violations. That lawsuit can be filed in state or federal courtroom in the United States. If it is filed in federal courtroom, it would probable be a 1983 civil rights lawsuit pursuant to 42 The statesC. § 1983.

Ceremonious lawsuits face the challenge that officers may exist protected by qualified immunity.

The false arrest lawsuit can demand aninjunction, which is a court lodge. If successful, the court can crave the police department to:

• retrain officers,
• modify their official policies for arresting, or
• fire the offending officer.

The lawsuit can also demandbudgetary damages. Those amercement would aim to recoup the victim for fake imprisonment. A personal injury attorney can assistance win bounty to cover:

• medical bills,
• wages lost,
• pain and suffering (mental distress), and
• the violation of the victim's civil rights, also known as presumed damages.

However, recovering monetary damages – peculiarly punitive damages – is difficult. Victims accept to overcome the qualified immunity defense. This defense shields government officials, including police officers, from lawsuits filed over acquit done while on duty.

6. What is the law in California?

In order to prevail on a California claim or lawsuit for imitation arrest, the plaintiff (victim) would need to prove the following elements:

1. The defendant (police officer) arrested the plaintiff without a warrant or with an invalid warrant;
2. The plaintiff was really harmed; and
3. The defendant'due south conduct was a substantial cistron causing the plaintiff's harm.¹¹

In one case a plaintiff alleges that the defendant arrested him/her without legal process, the burden rests on the defendant to justify the lawfulness of the arrest.¹² Mutual defenses that defendants raise are that they had probable cause to make an arrest, or that they had a practiced religion belief that the arrest warrant was valid.¹³

Defendants will likely claim that qualified immunity protects them from false abort lawsuits, though the statute is unclear whether qualified immunity applies to false arrests.¹⁴ Only as long as plaintiffs can show that defendants violated a articulate ramble correct, qualified immunity does not apply – and the defendants tin be sued.^fifteen

Plaintiffs bringing a false arrest lawsuit in California tin sue for monetary damages to comprehend the costs of any medical bills, lost wages, pain and suffering, emotional distress, and any other out-of-pocket costs. In most cases involving constabulary officers, their constabulary department pays any civil damages.¹⁶

---

Legal References:

driggersshopeors.blogspot.com

Source: https://www.shouselaw.com/ca/civil-rights/false-arrest/

Share this post